• Home
  • Articles
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contribute
  • Contact

Sceptical Scot

Asking Questions. Seeking Answers.

Home / Blog / Corbyn’s pick’n’mix approach to eating cake

Corbyn’s pick’n’mix approach to eating cake

March 11, 2018 by Denis MacShane 1 Comment

In his speech to the Scottish Labour Party conference, Jeremy Corbyn helpfully set out where he is on the EU and Brexit.

It is worth going through Corbyn’s speech in detail to see what makes sense to anyone sitting in an EU27 capital or the EU Commission. In a little over a year’s time there will be no more British MEPs, Ministers or officials able to take these arguments to the rest of the Europe. If Corbyn enters as prime minister on the basis of the Dundee programme on Europe he will be very alone as by then most bridges with Europe will have been blown up.

Corbyn said: “We would aim to negotiate a new and strong relationship with the single market and a floor under existing rights, standards and protections for workers, consumers and the environment.”

Comment: Third countries do not have a strong relationship with the single market. You are in in or you are not in it. There is no halfway house. A Labour government can legislate domestic laws for workers or the environment but will have no say on what the rest of Europe decides.

Corbyn : “We would want to negotiate protections or exemptions where necessary from current rules and directives that push privatisation and public service competition or restrict our ability to intervene to support domestic and local industry and business or undermine attempts to protect rights at work.”

Comment: Outside the EU the UK can do what it likes. It is not true to say nationalisation or state ownership is forbidden by the EU. There are plenty of models of ownership in Europe, often involving workers sitting on boards or devolved regional governments making laws to support local economic development. It is true that the kind of protectionist tariffs President Donald Trump wants to levy on British steel are illegal. But outside the combined strength of the EU, British steel and other workers will be exposed to any such levy or tariff that a more powerful trading partner chooses to impose.

Corbyn: “We cannot be held back from preventing employers being able to import cheap agency labour to undercut existing pay and conditions in the name of free market orthodoxy.”

Comment: It was Labour Britain 1997-2010 that did its best to delay the implementation of the European Agency Workers Directive which prevents exactly the kind of exploitation Corbyn highlights. The EU is also strengthening its Posted Workers Directive. The EU has no commitment to free market orthodoxy but rather it is the only international treaty organisation in the world which writes into enforceable law many worker protections.  Blaming Brussels for the failure of successive UK governments to enforce EU worker protection law is bizarre.

Corbyn: “We are determined to negotiate a deal that gives us full tariff-free access to the single market.”

Comment: Again, a nice aspiration but it is not tariff barriers that will prevent the 300,000 UK firms currently trading into the EU from having the same access as today. Real problems for industries like chemical and medicines are non-tariff rules. If a Labour government refuses to abide by these EU rules, the goods won’t easily be sold outside the UK. Labour’s pick ‘n’ mix, cake-and-eat  trade ambitions won’t succeed any more than Theresa May’s will. You are in the Single Market or not like you are pregnant or not. To anyone in the EU27 and Brussels in charge of the Single Market this statement will make no sense.

Corbyn: “We also need to be clear we could not accept a situation where we were subject to all EU rules and EU law, yet had no say in making those laws. That would leave us as mere rule-takers and isn’t a tenable position for a democracy.”

Comment: The UK can continue to make EU laws by staying in the EU. The idea that outside the EU anyone will notice anything what a Labour government says about what EU laws should or shouldn’t be is incoherent. Moreover, the Norway compromise of staying in the Single Market but outside the full EU Treaty membership has not threatened Norwegian democracy and it is rather patronising to a progressive Nordic nation close to Britain to suggest it is.

Corbyn: “We are also clear that the option of a new UK customs union with the EU would need to ensure the UK has a say in future trade deals.”

Comment: If a Labour-run UK seeks membership of the EU Customs Union it will have to abide by the trade deals of that Customs Union. Britain currently lies 15th in the EU league table of exports per capita. Germany exports four and a half time as much to China as the UK and does so happily within the EU Customs Union and Single Market. The UK can be like Turkey as a partial member of the Customs Union but the EU27 are unlikely to give Britain special trade privileges unknown in the history of customs union arrangements.

Corbyn: “Considerable delays for checks at ports and airports would cause real difficulties and costs for perishable goods such as seafood.That is why retaining the benefits of the customs union and the single market is vital to future Labour governments in both Holyrood and Westminster.”

Comment: Corbyn is 100 per cent right. But you cannot retain the “benefits of the customs union and single market” while rejecting membership of both. It is a political and logical impossibility.

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: Blog, Brexit, European Union, UK Tagged With: Brexit, EU referendum, Jeremy Corbyn, Scottish politics, UK Eurosceptics

About Denis MacShane

Born in Glasgow, Denis MacShane is a former trade union official who served as Minister for Europe under Tony Blair. He is author of Brexit: How Britain Will Leave Europe (IB Tauris, 2015)

Comments

  1. Gigi says

    March 12, 2018 at 8:21 am

    Thanks a lot for this overdue dissection of Corbyn’s/Thornberry’s fantasy Brexit cake. It hadn’t gotten the scrutiny in the media that it deserves because in many ways, Labour’s red velvet cake (as Brussels nicknamed this “vision”) is even more deluded than the Tories’ Brexit cake.

    What would be most interesting to know: Are all these people – May, Johnson, Davis, Gove, Fox, Corbyn, Thornberry, Starmer etc – really THAT deluded and clueless; or are they acting and posing to the British public, fully aware of the car crash that’s about to happen?

    That’s one of the biggest Brexit mysteries.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

About Sceptical Scot

Welcome to Sceptical Scot, Scotland’s premier non-tribal forum for passionate, informed debate. Sceptical Scot is for all who care about Scotland’s future, regardless of how they vote: for party, independence or union, EU or Brexit. We aim to provide an arena that is both broader and deeper than current online/print offers with a rich diet of well-researched, polemical, thought-provoking writing. Read more »

What’s new on Sceptical Scot

  • Brexit’s multi-billion hit on Scotland’s economy February 22, 2019
  • So sorry, England February 17, 2019
  • The parochialism of the present February 15, 2019
  • Local government blame game February 14, 2019
  • Sex and gender identity in the 2021 Census February 13, 2019
  • A question of trust February 7, 2019
  • Best Scottish Poetry offers escape to reality February 5, 2019
  • George Square 1919: no real revolutionary threat? January 31, 2019
  • Scottish exports: where they really go January 30, 2019
  • Brexit, SNP and Indy January 29, 2019

The Sceptical Newsletter

The Sceptical Scot cartoon

Can satire bring Brexit Britain to its senses?

Categories

  • Articles (400)
  • Blog (371)
  • Books & Poetry (17)
  • Brexit (147)
  • Criminal justice (16)
  • Culture (179)
  • Economics (162)
  • Economy (6)
  • Education (47)
  • Elections (127)
  • Environment (23)
  • European Union (200)
  • Featured (40)
  • federalism (7)
  • Federalism (3)
  • Health (31)
  • History (35)
  • Housing (14)
  • Humour (9)
  • Independence (178)
  • Inequality (50)
  • Local government (42)
  • Longer reads (49)
  • Podcast (1)
  • Poetry (49)
  • Policy (106)
  • Politics (166)
  • Polls and quizzes (1)
  • Reviews (23)
  • Social democracy (74)
  • Trump (6)
  • UK (240)

Archives

SUPPORT US

Help keep Sceptical Scot running ad-free and posting great quality writing. Click here to donate.

Recommended

  • Bella Caledonia
  • Centre on Constitutional Change
  • The UK in a Changing Europe
  • Common Space
  • Gerry Hassan
  • Scottish Review
  • Social Europe
  • Think Scotland
My Tweets

© 2019 Sceptical Scot · Privacy and Cookies · About this Site