Every early death, like that of Karen McDade who died in Dundee aged 43, is a tragedy for that person and their family. Sadly, an increasing number of families in Scotland are affected by these tragedies.
In 2018, 1,187 people died as a result of drugs. This is a record, up 27% compared with 2017, and in just a decade up 107% from 2008. Scotland’s drug death rate is now nearly three times that of the UK as a whole.
Scottish ministers admit that it’s a public health emergency, but far too little is being done to save these lives.
The loss of life, particularly among those aged between 35 and 55, is such that drug-related deaths are affecting life expectancy trends for Scotland. Although most (76%) deaths were of older drug users (that is, those aged 35 years and older), there is a worrying increase in the number (282) of deaths of younger adults (up from 170 in 2013).
The number of deaths among women has also risen rapidly in recent years to 327, which is 189% higher than in 2008. Opioids, such as heroin, morphine and methadone, are involved in most (86%) drug deaths, but they are rarely taken in isolation. The use of more than one substance is a factor in 85% of all fatalities. This is heavily influenced by street drugs, such as cocaine and illicit benzodiazepines, which are increasingly implicated in drug deaths, and also prescribed drugs, such as pregabalin and gabapentin. Deaths are highest among working-class people in deprived areas, who have often been ignored in British drug policy making.
Earlier this month, Joe Fitzpatrick, the public health minister of the Scottish government, called the rise in drug deaths an emergency. “We need to act,” he said. His words echoed a recent call in The Lancet by the UK’s leading experts on the treatment of heroin dependence for drug-related deaths to be treated as a public health crisis. But when asked what action he was taking to deal with this emergency, Fitzpatrick didn’t refer to a new initiative, funding or legislation but to the drug-death taskforce he has set up.
Solutions left on shelves
There is a lot to learn about the causes and solutions of Scotland’s epidemic of drug-related deaths. But we already know some steps that could be taken, as they were recommended by both the UK Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs in 2016, the Staying Alive in Scotlandreport of the same year, and the expert review of opioid replacement therapy in Scotland of 2013. These include providing more and better substitution therapies for people who use heroin, with optimal dosage and duration of methadone treatment, providing heroin-assisted treatment, and expanding other harm-reduction services.
The controversy over the stalled idea to open a safer drug consumption room in Glasgow is not the only example of the lack of progress in implementing these recommendations.
This latest bout of political inertia contrasts with Scotland’s world-leading approach to take-home naloxone (the antidote to opioid overdose), which was implemented nationally in 2011 and cited as an example of best practice by the World Health Organisation. Without this, the latest drug-related death figures may well have been even higher.
Extra investment of £20m per year until 2021 in drug and alcohol treatment is much needed, but this was announced in response to a widely criticised £15m cut in 2016-17. It falls far short of what is required to address a public health crisis.
A new drug and alcohol treatment strategy published in November 2018 received widespread acclaim for adopting a public health approach to reduce harms, but an action plan to support its implementation is still awaited eight months on.
We cannot go on like this. Every year since 2014, steep annual increases in drug-related deaths have been met with promises to look into causes and propose solutions. Meanwhile, people continue to die, as evidence-based and life-saving solutions are left on the shelf. This is an emergency, so let’s treat it as an emergency and get on with acting, as well as investigating.
The record number of drug deaths prompted a lot of soul-searching among policy-makers and experts and, unfortunately, a lot of naked politicking by parties keen to pin the blame for the emergency on the UK Government or the Scottish Government…Three of the more thoughtful articles in response came from Dani Garavelli in The Scotsman, Libby Brooks of The Guardian and Ben Wray of Common Space:
Dani Garavelli, Hard questions not glibn answers, July 21 2019
Libby Brooks, Scotland records huge rise in drug-related deaths, July 16 2019
Ben Wray, Blame Westminster and 20 years of conformist Holyrood, July 16 2019
Here’s what we published two years ago on the drugs death crisis
And here we engage with Alison Thewliss SNP MP: