• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contribute
  • Contact

Sceptical Scot

Asking Questions. Seeking Answers.

You are here: Home / Blog / Humza faces a hard landing

Humza faces a hard landing

March 27, 2023 by David Gow Leave a Comment

The SNP leadership election result mirrored the Brexit vote: 52-48%. Will it prove as fractious as the EU referendum of 2016 that continues to divide the UK?

It certainly suggests that the SNP is split down the middle between social democratic/social liberal and economically and socially conservative wings. And that its grasp on power is loosening after almost 16 years.

The pretty derisory 11% first preferences for Ash Regan confirms that the Alba ‘insurgency’ is already a spent force. On the other hand, Kate Forbes’s 47.9% in the second round suggests that the days of the centralising, semi-autocratic rule of the party leadership under Nicola Sturgeon and Peter Murrell are over. Had she had more time to prepare her campaign she might well have (deservedly) won: taking on the SNP  ‘establishment’/Scottish Government and galvanising a ‘revolt’ by the party base clearly won more backing as the truncated campaign progressed.

Hardly surprising, then, that Humza Yousaf – criticised by his rivals as the embodiment of SNP failure in government – talked of change rather than continuity. From his opening citation of the legacy of Labour leader John Smith, he effectively talked of a fresh start: on poverty, criminal justice reform, health service delivery, small business support, social and economic revival. Long promised by his predecessors; patchily delivered if at all.

He made two striking promises: to enable Scotland as “a European nation” to return to the EU and, of course, to be part of/command the “generation that delivers independence for Scotland.” He’s young (38 on April 7) but both these goals will be hard to deliver within a decade and, even with the best will in the world, the next 12-15 years. What’s more, his tenure at the top of party and government may prove short if election results next year and again in 2026 go the wrong way as well they might.

That’s for the days and months ahead to decide. They may prove tough, cruel even for the “first Muslim to be elected as national leader in any western democracy” (h/t @sundersays) and (almost certainly) first ethnic minority leader of the Scottish Government. That should merit some goodwill for Humza Yousaf. He won’t enjoy it for long, if at all. If Sturgeon’s reputation is already being shredded, he doesn’t have one to defend. A hard rain gonna fall on him. And, more than likely, his party too.

Featured image via Scottish Government flickr CC BY-SA 2.0

See also: Severin Carrell, Continuity candidate, Guardian; How Humza Yousaf secured victory, Herald

Filed Under: Blog, Brexit, Independence, Politics Tagged With: Scottish Government, Scottish politics

About David Gow

David Gow FRSE co-edits sceptical.scot. He is also a senior adviser of Social Europe and a former European Business Editor and Germany Correspondent at The Guardian. He contributed to The Red Paper on Scotland (1975). He co-wrote Basta! An end to austerity politics (2013). He lives in Edinburgh and St Fillans.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

About Sceptical Scot

Welcome to Sceptical Scot, Scotland’s premier non-tribal forum for passionate, informed debate. Sceptical Scot is for all who care about Scotland’s future, regardless of how they vote: for party, independence or union, EU or Brexit. We aim to provide an arena that is both broader and deeper than current online/print offers with a rich diet of well-researched, polemical, thought-provoking writing. Read more » about About Sceptical Scot

What’s new on Sceptical Scot

  • A fresh start: time to make devo really work May 28, 2023
  • UK-wide constitutional reform is an unavoidable must May 25, 2023
  • Scotland’s centres of power need reform: Part 2 (Holyrood) May 15, 2023
  • Scotland’s centres of power need reform: Part 1 (Westminster) May 14, 2023
  • Rewilding the Highlands: Glen Affric and Dundreggan point the way May 13, 2023
  • Plotting Scotland’s unsettled future May 11, 2023
  • Forget the tough talk and flag waving, Labour May 11, 2023
  • Will Scotland switch to Labour in a big way? May 9, 2023
  • The desire for change May 7, 2023
  • What’s going on at the SNP? April 22, 2023

The Sceptical Newsletter

The Sceptical Scot cartoon

Categories

  • Articles (669)
  • Blog (550)
  • Books & Poetry (26)
  • Brexit (210)
  • climate crisis (6)
  • climate crisis (29)
  • Covid19 (65)
  • Criminal justice (17)
  • Culture (307)
  • Devo20 (1)
  • Economics (191)
  • Economy (113)
  • Education (75)
  • Elections (189)
  • Energy (1)
  • Environment (68)
  • European Union (261)
  • Featured (42)
  • Federalism (20)
  • federalism (14)
  • Health (65)
  • History (72)
  • Housing (24)
  • Humour (11)
  • identity (16)
  • Independence (281)
  • Inequality (78)
  • International (37)
  • Ireland (8)
  • Ireland (6)
  • Local government (84)
  • Longer reads (74)
  • Media (11)
  • Podcast (3)
  • Poetry (72)
  • Policy (225)
  • Politics (352)
  • Polls and quizzes (1)
  • Reviews (24)
  • Social democracy (85)
  • Trump (10)
  • UK (352)
  • Uncategorized (6)

Sceptical Scot elsewhere

Facebook
Twitter

Footer

About Sceptical Scot

Since 2014 Sceptical Scot has offered a non-tribal forum for passionate, informed debate for all who care about Scotland’s future

Recommended

  • Bella Caledonia
  • Centre on Constitutional Change
  • The UK in a Changing Europe
  • Common Space
  • Gerry Hassan
  • Scottish Review
  • Social Europe
  • Think Scotland

Archives

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in