• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contribute
  • Contact

Sceptical Scot

Asking Questions. Seeking Answers.

You are here: Home / Blog / Keep troops happy – and powder dry

Keep troops happy – and powder dry

October 15, 2016 by Paul Cairney Leave a Comment

Nicola Sturgeon has announced a consultation on a new Bill on Scottish Independence.

Clearly, it made the audience at the SNP’s conference very happy, but what should the rest of us make of it? My gut tells me there will be a second referendum but I wouldn’t yet bet my house on it, because that decision is wrapped up in three unresolved issues.

First, there won’t be a referendum unless the SNP thinks it will win, but the polls won’t tell us the answer before Sturgeon has to ask the question! It sounds simple to hold back a referendum until enough people tell you they’ll vote Yes. The complication is that many people don’t know what their choice will be until they can make sense of recent events. ‘Brexit’ might be a ‘game changer’ in a year or two, but it isn’t right now, and Sturgeon might have to choose to pursue a referendum before those polls change in her favour.

Second, the polls don’t tell us much because it is too soon to know what Brexit will look like. The idea of Brexit is still too abstract and not yet related to the arguments that might win the day for a Yes vote.

In each case, I don’t think we can expect to see the full effect of such arguments because (a) they don’t yet form part of a coherent argument linked directly to Brexit, because (b) we still don’t yet know what Brexit looks like. If you don’t really know what something is, how it relates to your life, and who you should blame for that outcome, how can you express a view on its effect on your political preferences?

Third, it is therefore too soon to know how different the second Scottish independence referendum would be. The SNP would like it to relate to the constitutional crisis caused by Brexit, basing its case on a combination of simple statements: England is pulling Scotland out of the EU against our will; the Tories caused this problem; we want to clear up the mess that they caused; it’s a bit rich for the Tories to warn us about the disastrous economic consequences of Scottish independence after the havoc they just caused; and, we want to be a cosmopolitan Scotland, not little England.

Instead, what if people see the Leave vote as a cautionary tale? It is not easy to argue that our response to the catastrophic effect of a withdrawal from a major political, economic, and social union should be to withdraw from another major political, economic, and social union. This is particularly true now that Brexit has opened up the possibility of more devolution (a possibility that had been closed off before now). A feasible alternative is to push for more autonomy in the areas that are devolved and ‘Europeanised’ – including agriculture, fishing, and environmental policies – as a way to have the UK deal with the Scottish Government  ‘as equals on a range of areas’.

So, I’d describe Sturgeon’s announcement as a short term win: why not give your most active audience something to cheer about while you wait for events to unfold? Predicting the timing of a referendum is more difficult because it relates more to a concept than a date: it will be the point at which (a) we know enough about the meaning of Brexit to judge its likely impact, and (b) we have to decide before it feels too late (in other words, in time to respond to the timetable of the UK’s exit from the EU).

Some people are worrying that the UK Government might scupper the SNP’s chances directly, by withholding consent for a second referendum. Maybe it would be better to be tricksy indirectly, by remaining vague about the impact of Brexit and having people in Scotland worry about making a choice before they know its effect.

A version of this post appeared on the author’s own site (and elsewhere)

 

Filed Under: Blog, Brexit, Independence, UK Tagged With: EU referendum, Europe, indyref2, Scottish politics

About Paul Cairney

Paul Cairney is Professor of Politics and Public Policy at Stirling University after starting his academic career in Aberdeen.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

About Sceptical Scot

Welcome to Sceptical Scot, Scotland’s premier non-tribal forum for passionate, informed debate. Sceptical Scot is for all who care about Scotland’s future, regardless of how they vote: for party, independence or union, EU or Brexit. We aim to provide an arena that is both broader and deeper than current online/print offers with a rich diet of well-researched, polemical, thought-provoking writing. Read more » about About Sceptical Scot

What’s new on Sceptical Scot

  • Starmer Y1: what now for Scotland and a fractured union? July 4, 2025
  • Why Israel won’t stick to any ceasefire in Gaza/Iran brokered by Trump July 4, 2025
  • Should the Scottish Government fund public interest journalism? June 29, 2025
  • Fiscal challenges for the Scottish Government, Pt 96 June 29, 2025
  • Make Europe Great Again June 18, 2025
  • The spending rollercoaster is well and truly back June 13, 2025
  • The fragmenting map of Scottish politics June 9, 2025
  • Scottish paradox: a £704m boom on a foundation of sand June 9, 2025
  • Are Scotland’s ferries too cheap? May 31, 2025
  • More green energy jobs May 31, 2025

The Sceptical Newsletter

The Sceptical Scot cartoon

Categories

  • anti-fascism (10)
  • Articles (714)
  • Blog (663)
  • Books & Poetry (27)
  • Brexit (231)
  • climate crisis (9)
  • climate crisis (53)
  • Covid19 (67)
  • Criminal justice (19)
  • Culture (335)
  • Devo20 (1)
  • Economics (202)
  • Economy (170)
  • Education (83)
  • Elections (241)
  • Energy (12)
  • Environment (102)
  • European Union (294)
  • Featured (42)
  • Federalism (23)
  • federalism (15)
  • Health (70)
  • History (93)
  • Housing (28)
  • Humour (11)
  • identity (32)
  • Independence (318)
  • Inequality (87)
  • International (77)
  • Ireland (8)
  • Ireland (13)
  • Local government (95)
  • Longer reads (78)
  • Media (15)
  • Podcast (4)
  • Poetry (73)
  • Policy (302)
  • Politics (459)
  • Polls and quizzes (2)
  • protest song (1)
  • Reviews (25)
  • Social democracy (91)
  • Trump (21)
  • UK (417)
  • Uncategorized (14)

Sceptical Scot elsewhere

Facebook
Twitter

Footer

About Sceptical Scot

Since 2014 Sceptical Scot has offered a non-tribal forum for passionate, informed debate for all who care about Scotland’s future

Recommended

  • Bella Caledonia
  • Centre on Constitutional Change
  • The UK in a Changing Europe
  • Common Space
  • Gerry Hassan
  • Scottish Review
  • Social Europe
  • Think Scotland

Archives

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in